Predatory Journal &  Preliminary Check Service 

Predatory Journals deceive authors by publishing their papers for a fee without doing the peer review and other editorial services provided by legitimate publishers.

What are Predatory Journals / Publishers

Resources

Identifying Predatory Publishers
(2:15)

Think. Check. Submit.
(1:58)

About Predatory Journals

Predatory journals and publishers are entities that prioritize self-interest at the expense of scholarship and are characterized by false or misleading information, deviation from best editorial and publication practices, a lack of transparency, and/or the use of aggressive and indiscriminate solicitation practices.

Reference → Predatory journals: no definition, no defence, Nature. (December 11, 2019)

The concept of ‘predatory’ journals has many names: fake journals, questionable journals, illegitimate journals, deceptive journals, dark journals, and journals “operating in bad faith”.

Reference → About Predatory Publishing - Think. Check. Submit

(1) Asking authors to publish for a fee (Open Access model)
(2) Fail to follow the accepted standards of publishing peer reviewed research.
(3) Exist only to make money, not to advance scholarship and knowledge.
(4) Often send out mass emails soliciting for articles or people to serve as editors or peer reviewers.

Reference → Be wary of predatory journals, University of Missouri Libraries
 

Mega journals are open access, peer-reviewed, have a broad subject scope, the research articles are judged by scientific and methodological soundness, which causes the low rejection rate has made the journals growing big, PLoS One (ISSN 1932-6203) was the first mega journal and has been very successful, the publishing model was then imitated by other publishers. 

The perception to mega journals are varied, we suggest DO NOT list mega journal article as your representative or reference publications for faculty promotion nor for application for the national-level research grant.

ResourcesWhat you must know About mega journals, TMU Library

Library Support

Mobirise
Preliminary Check Service for Predatory Journal

We won't tell you if it is a predatory journal or not. We only provide information that can help you make a decision: submit your manuscript to the journal or choose another journal. Feel free to contact us if you have any questions.
Apply for the Preliminary Check Report

Eligible User

Current TMU and affiliate Hospital faculty, doctoral students and staff.

Turnaround Time

1-2 normal business days.

What the library check

We will check...
[1] Does the journal have a real Journal Impact Factor(JIF)?
[2] Is the journal (or its publisher) listed on the blacklist?
[3] Is the journal indexed in Medline?
[4] Additional information

What will you receive

You will receive a pdf file. It contains the results that the library checks for you and a check list. You can follow the check list to evaluate the journal by yourself.

Self-evaluation Tools

  • The Retraction Watch Hijacked Journal Checker
    Created by the Retraction Watch and Abalkina. This resource is dynamic; more journals will be added as their hijacked status are uncovered.
  • NLM Catalog (for medical journals)
    Where you may confirm whether the journal indexed is in Medline or not. If the record says "Not currently indexed for MEDLINE", it means that the journal may be questionable. 
  • InCites JCR
    Predatory journals often publish fake impact factors, or do not list one at all. You can check a journal title's impact factor via InCites JCR. (Don't forget to connect TMU-VPN when you are off the TMU campus.)

Having problems? Contact us

Taipei Medical University Library
Reference Desk

Email: asktmul@tmu.edu.tw
Location: 3F, Comprehensive Medical Building (Rear Building), Xin-Yi Campus

Taipei Medical University Hospital
Ms. Chien

Email: asktmul@tmu.edu.tw
Location: 3F, Comprehensive Medical Building (Rear Building), Xin-Yi Campus

Wan Fang Hospital
Information Desk

Tel: 02 2930-7930 ext.8912 
Email: asktmul@w.tmu.edu.tw

Shuang Ho Hospital
Information Desk

Tel: 02 2249-0088 ext.8930
Email: library@s.tmu.edu.tw

© Copyright 2022 Taipei Medical University Library. All Rights Reserved.

Designed with Mobirise - Try here